featured image for podcast episodeBrad connects with Martin and Ayesha

Brad connects with Martin and Ayesha
Episode 251

Choose
Posted by Choose FI

Episode Guide

Episode Summary:

The discussion revolves around the financial independence journey of Martin and Asia, a couple who share their transition from being natural savers to actively pursuing financial independence. They reveal how discovering financial strategies, such as Roth IRA conversions and dividend funds, changed their perspective on budgeting and investment. Instead of restrictive budgeting, they focus on spending aligned with personal values and experiences, opting for cost-effective solutions like potlucks over dining out. The couple discusses the importance of re-evaluating their financial goals, particularly the desire to pay off their mortgage, debating different strategies and the psychological impact of eliminating debt. Their experience underscores the significance of community support in achieving financial goals, as they seek guidance from Brad and Jonathan to navigate their path to financial independence.

Episode Timestamps

ChooseFI Podcast Episode Show Notes

Episode Title: Should Paying Off a Mortgage Be Part of Your Financial Independence Plan?

Episode Summary:
Martin and Asia, natural savers, share their journey towards financial independence after discovering the ChooseFI podcast. They discuss their success in optimizing savings, the role of family during quarantine, and the psychological aspects of mortgage payoff decisions. The conversation emphasizes personal finance strategies, budgeting methods, and the importance of community support in pursuing financial independence.

Podcast Hosts:

  • Brad Barrett
  • Jonathan Mendonsa

Guests:

  • Martin
  • Asia

Key Topics & Takeaways

  • Introduction and Background

    • Brad welcomes guests Martin and Asia, discussing their background and how they discovered financial independence (FI).

  • Discussion on Financial Independence

    • Martin and Asia highlight their natural saving habits and their transformation after discovering the concept of FI.
    • They share their progression from general saving to a focused and strategic approach toward financial independence.

  • The Importance of Family Time

    • Their experiences during COVID-19 clarified the value of family time over material consumption.
    • Martin discusses how the quarantine provided insights into what truly matters, emphasizing quality family interactions.

  • Options for Mortgage Payoff

    • The couple analyzes various mortgage payoff strategies, weighing the psychological comfort of being mortgage-free against investment opportunities.
    • Insights on how mortgage decisions relate to their FI goals are shared, focusing on the emotional aspects of debt.

  • Conclusion and Insights

    • Reflecting on their journey, Martin and Asia express their goal of achieving combined happiness and financial independence, balancing their values with actionable financial strategies.

Actionable Takeaways

  • Focus on experiences that bring joy rather than on material consumption.
  • Consider budgeting as a tool for better financial tracking rather than a restrictive measure.
  • Evaluate how mortgage decisions align with both financial goals and emotional comfort.

Key Quotes

  • "Shifting our spending focus to what truly brings us value leads to fulfillment."
  • "The irreplaceable value of family time is a transformative realization."
  • "Financial security often begins with the peace of mind that comes from mortgage freedom."
  • Personal Capital - A tool for tracking expenses and investments.
  • Budget Bites - A website providing affordable meal options and recipe ideas.

FAQs

  • Should I pay off my mortgage as part of my financial independence plan?
    It depends on your personal goals and feelings about debt. For some, paying off the mortgage provides peace of mind and security.

  • What financial tools can help with budgeting?
    Using tools like Personal Capital can streamline tracking expenses and investments, making budgeting less cumbersome.

Discussion Questions

  • How has COVID-19 influenced your perspective on financial priorities?
  • What strategies have you used to optimize your family's budget?
  • How do you weigh the psychological comfort of being debt-free against potential investment gains?

Podcast Intro:
You're listening to ChooseFI. The blueprint for financial independence lives here...

Podcast Extro:
You've been listening to ChooseFI Podcast, where we help middle-class America build wealth one life hack at a time.

The Path to Financial Independence: Balancing Mortgage Payoff and Life Fulfillment

Many individuals and families dream of achieving financial independence (FI), a state where one has sufficient wealth to live without needing to work actively for basic necessities. However, the journey toward financial independence can be complex, especially when evaluating the significance of paying off a mortgage. In this article, we will explore actionable strategies for optimizing savings, balancing financial security with personal values, and embracing a fulfilling lifestyle.

Understanding Financial Independence and the Role of Mortgages

Financial independence offers a unique opportunity to reevaluate financial priorities. For some families like Martin and Asia, the realization that paying off a mortgage could influence their peace of mind and overall happiness. The psychological comfort of being mortgage-free often outweighs mathematical efficiency. Before making any decisions, it’s essential to deeply understand what financial independence means for you personally and what expenses, including a mortgage, impact your sense of security.

Evaluating Your Financial Landscape

  1. Create a Detailed Budget
    Start by creating a detailed budget. An accurate depiction of your finances is vital for understanding where money is being spent and where savings can be found. Review all expenses, focusing on non-discretionary items that can be trimmed without sacrificing quality of life. By knowing your financial landscape, you can better assess if paying off your mortgage aligns with your long-term goals.

  2. Utilize Budgeting Tools
    Tools like Personal Capital provide a streamlined approach to tracking expenses and investments. By inputting your financial information, you can gain a clearer view of your budgeting habits, pinpoint areas for improvement, and redirect helped funds toward savings or mortgage repayment.

  3. Consider Your Values
    Assess what brings you joy in life. Shifting your spending to focus on experiences rather than material possessions can lead to greater fulfillment. Do you cherish family gatherings? Consider hosting potluck dinners or engaging in local adventures that create lasting memories while being financial-friendly.

Strategies for Mortgage Payoff

When weighing mortgage payoff against potential investment gains, consider the following strategies:

  1. Understand Your Options
    Martin and Asia presented multiple options for addressing their mortgage. It’s crucial to evaluate each option based on potential emotional comfort, overall financial situation, and the mathematical outcomes.

    • Paying off the mortgage fully might reduce monthly expenses and free them from debt altogether.
    • Utilizing investment accounts to pay down mortgage balances can lead to significant gains, but this comes with emotional trade-offs.

  2. Psychological Comfort is Key
    Acknowledge that while paying off a mortgage is mathematically suboptimal in many cases, the peace of mind it brings can enhance overall life satisfaction. If if it means planning further reductions in your non-discretionary spending during the financial independence journey, identify how much you need to invest each month to reach your goals while minimizing stress.

  3. Leverage Professional Advice
    Seek advice from financial professionals, particularly regarding investment strategies and mortgage options. Calculating scenarios using an amortization calculator can help visualize how different repayment strategies impact your long-term financial health while providing clarity on your path toward financial independence.

Building a Fulfilling Life

Achieving financial independence involves more than accumulating wealth; it's about designing a life where your time is spent on what matters. As you journey toward FI, consider the following:

  1. Redefine Success
    Identify what success looks like for you and your family. Understand your core values and align your financial decisions accordingly. Remember that moments with family often hold more significance than temporary monetary gains.

  2. Promote Transparency Around Money
    Foster an environment where money discussions are normalized, especially regarding children's education. Encourage open dialogue about finances, investments, and potential alternative paths, such as vocational training or scholarships. This transparency not only prepares them for adulthood but also instills a sense of financial responsibility.

  3. Make Time for Family and Personal Growth
    As emphasized by Martin and Asia, the lockdown sparked a revelation about the irreplaceable value of family time. Recognizing what truly matters is crucial. Engaging in family activities, such as game nights or outdoor adventures, allows for connection and joy without the financial burden often associated with conventional leisure activities.

Conclusion: Embracing the Journey

The path to financial independence is personal and ever-evolving. By evaluating your financial landscape, understanding your mortgage options, focusing on experiences rather than possessions, and fostering financial literacy within your family, you can carve out a fulfilling, stable life.

Be patient and compassionate with yourself during this journey. Remember, financial independence is a process, not a destination. As you navigate this financial terrain, keep in mind that the freedom to live life on your terms, spend time with loved ones, and find joy in experiences inherently fuels the pursuit of a richer, more meaningful existence.

[elementor-template id="143609"]

What You'll Get Out Of Today's Show

  • Martin and Ayesha are both natural savers who have been great about living below their means but lacked a real plan. Their goals are to maximize investments for retirement and finding ways to utilize dividend funds.
  • After stumbling across the ChooseFI podcast, they felt like their financial independence number and retirement seemed obtainable which has helped push them to commit and make even bigger changes.
  • While Martin and Ayesha had a 20-25% savings rate before finding FI, Brad commended them on what a great job they were doing. He also stressed that FI is about living a better life and having the financial security to get you there, not what your savings rate is.
  • Despite the inclination to save, Ayesha always resisted the thought of meticulousness and restrictive budgets. However, she found that she could get behind the idea of focusing on spending on what they truly valued, so they began using Personal Capital as a less obtrusive method of tracking their spending and gaining insight into their habits.
  • Something that Martin and Ayesha place considerable value on are experiences, particularly travel, spending time with friends and family, and being healthy. Instead of getting together at restaurants and spending money on pricey meals out, they began hosting monthly potlucks.
  • Ayesha has found the website Budget Bytes to be incredibly economical when it comes to low-cost recipes and efficient for discovering uses for the ingredients she already has in her refrigerator. It's helped to cut their grocery bill to around $600 per month for their family of 4.
  • Due to quarantine restrictions, Ayesha was out of work for months, which she calls a blessing in disguise. During that free time, they were able to take a deep dive into their spending and immediately saved $500. It also allowed them to slow down and spend more time with family enjoying the outdoors, playing games, and eating all three meals together.
  • Following the time off from work, Ayesha has realized that it does cause her some stress which made her want to buy things. It also strengthened her conviction to reduce her workload within 5 years to perhaps just one day a week so that she can find more joy in the moment.
  • Although Martin enjoyed his two-hour daily commute, working from home during the pandemic has made him more aware of the importance of time. He now strives to make the most of his time and focus on using it in ways that bring him the most value.
  • While their monthly expenses are not constant because life is lumpy, it runs around $3,500 but can go as high as $5,000 a month when home repairs are needed.
  • Martin and Ayesha have a goal of reaching FI in seven years and are looking at exploring several different options to help get them there.
  • With option one, they would withdraw money from an investment account to pay off the mortgage on their home. The money saved on the mortgage payment would then be invested for the next seven years.
  • In option two, they would use their investment account to pay off half of the remaining mortgage and continue to make the monthly mortgage payments which result in a mortgage pay off in seven years.
  • Their third option is to refinance their current mortgage which has 17 years left at 3.3% interest rate to a 15-year loan at 2.6%, but that refinance incurs $7,000 in fees. The payments would remain the same, but the home would be paid off two years earlier.
  • Ayesha likes the idea of not having a mortgage but doesn't want to do it if the numbers don't make sense. However, Martin is okay with a lower net worth if it means they can get rid of their mortgage because he feels they would have more options.
  • Brad admits this is an issue he and many others in the FI community struggle with. With such low-interest rates on mortgages, it's almost always a better option mathematically to keep the money invested, but it doesn't mean it's the right decision for everyone. The psychological aspect needs to be considered.
  • If they would like to pay the mortgage off in seven years, the best thing they can do it to use an amortization calculator and see how much extra they will need to pay each month to have the mortgage paid off in seven years. Martin and Ayesha can then see how that payment fits into their current lifestyle.
  • As a fourth option, Brad pointed out that they can drastically reduce their FI number if they were to pay off their mortgage. With a FI estimate of 1.25 million, using the 4% rule, they would have $4,000 per month. If the mortgage was paid off, they could reduce their monthly expenses by $1,600, and then their FI number is only $750,000.
  • After living through the 2008 housing market crash and not having a plan, and then this most recent market downturn, Martin and Ayesha have realized they may not be as risk-tolerant as they used to believe. Brad suggested having an investor policy statement that they've written down to help them stay the course in times of uncertainty.
  • The biggest takeaway is the being on the path to FI gives you options when you have the freedom and flexibility to create a plan that works to meet your goals and live a better life, even if it isn't always mathematically optimized.
  • It's a common problem to be overwhelmed with all the information we consume about optimizing various aspects of our lives that we end up with analysis paralysis. It's important to remember that we're trying to live better lives. They don't have to perfect or 100% optimized.
  • One final concern Martin and Ayesha have is funding their children's education. Brad admits it may be wishful thinking that the higher education system goes through some sort of dramatic change in the coming years, but he and Laura consider paying $50,000 a year for college to be unpalatable and have stopped putting money into their girls' 529 accounts. Instead, they have tried to normalize the conversation about money in their house and have discussed lower-cost options for college.

Resources Mentioned In Today's Conversation

← Back