Should I limit my Roth conversions this year in order to stay under the AGI limit to get the $2500 tax credit for my kid in college, or forego the tax credit and "go big" on conversions? I am newly retired this year, 60 yo. My pre-tax trad. IRA retirement account (formerly 401k) is very large, and my retirement plan using ProjectionLab indicates to go big on Roth conversions starting now, like fill up the 24% marginal tax bracket, for best long-term results (lowest lifetime tax paid, etc.). This would blow my AGI way past the $160-180k phase-out limit for joint filers for the AOTC college tax credit of $2500 . On the other hand, Cody Garrett and Sean Mullaney made a compelling argument in their book "Tax Planning to and Through Early Retirement" that the difference between doing Roth conversions in early retirement (and having smaller RMDs later) vs. not doing them (and having bigger RMDs later) is not as big as people think and close to "in the noise". Philosophically I like doing big Roth conversions now as tax-rate arbitrage (buy the tax now while it's "on sale"). I can forego tax deductions without losing sleep, but I hate to walk away from a tax credit.
New to Tax Strategies?
Read our Complete Tax Strategies Guide →Limit Roth Conversions to Get a College Tax Credit?
Planning to retire before 59½?
Access your retirement funds early and penalty-free with this essential tax strategy.
The Roth Conversion LadderReplies (8)
brub888
873 XP2 days ago
The top of the 2026 MFJ 24% bracket is taxable income of $403.55K which means if you take the std deduction a MAGI of at least $435.75K. This is ~$276K more than the MAGI level ($160K) to get the full AOTC. The AOTC is less than 1% of the "extra" Roth conversion.
You would need to run the numbers, but if you have cash to pay the extra taxes, my strong instinct is converting would be advantageous. You want to be sure to include Federal taxes + NIIT + State taxes + any lost credits if you continue to do similar conversions up to age 70 (e.g. ACA credits, IRMAA [age 63+], additional senior deduction [if extended past 2028] ).
If this is legacy money you intend to bequeath, you would get tax-free growth for you and your spouse's lifetime plus ten more years for an heir. Moreover, you are insulated from the widow's tax trap (smaller tax brackets for Singles) when you or your spouse dies.
If you intend to die with zero, the Roth accounts are less advantageous. If you do not start Roth conversions and your pretax accounts compound at 7%, they will increase by 2.75X by the time you hit RMD age of 75. Eventually all pretax money will be taxed either via RMDs by you or if you have a human beneficiary.
John Dovey
123 XP2 days ago
Thanks for the comments, Brub888. Rings true. A colleague of mine in a similar situation is doing big Roth conversions as well, like $400-500k / year, under the guidance of his financial adviser. I may run some more numbers on this, but my gut feel was the $2500 tax credit near-term is surpassed by the longer term effects of conversions.
brub888
873 XP2 days ago
If your child expects to attend and pay for grad or professional school and they are not a dependent for tax purposes at the time, they can get the credits. The AGI phaseouts for both credits are the same.
An individual student is eligible for the American Opportunity Tax Credit (AOTC) for a maximum of 4 tax years [$2.5K/yr max with 40% refundable], while the Lifetime Learning Credit (LLC) has no limit on the number of years it can be claimed [20% up to $10K = $2K/yr max, not refundable].
PattyIce
227 XP2 days ago
I'd agree that it's in the noise, but $2500 is $2500… How many more years are you expecting to use the college tax credit? Is 160k well above your annual spend?
John Dovey
123 XP2 days ago
I have possibly 4-5 more years of the college tax credit depending on what younger kid #2 does after high school. Annual spend is below $160k this year. Long term, a legacy and/or charitable donations are certainly in the picture.
PattyIce
227 XP2 days ago
If charitable giving is part of your plan, I believe Qualified Charitable Distributions could help if you see RMDs as a "problem".
Also, in regards to the Brub888 comment, the 24% tax bracket being up at 435k (which I didn't know was that high when I made my first comment), means you're dealing with an order of magnitude more money than I assumed. The $2500 tax credit is equally in the noise…
BostonFI
6,489 XP1 day ago
I also came to the conclusion that large RMDs aren't a problem because of QCDs. If I reach age 75+ and am facing an exorbitant RMD, it's because I have failed to make good use of my money by spending or gifting it and so I should take the Red Hot Chili Peppers route and give it away now.
John Dovey
123 XP2 days ago
I love the idea of QCDs and plan to utilize them in a decade (when I pass 70 ½ YO God willing . . ).