ChooseFI — Go to home page
The Real Lesson From Buffett's Famous Bet
ChooseFI Weekly

The Real Lesson From Buffett's Famous Bet

Brad Barrett
By Brad Barrett · · 7 min read
choosefi logo on coffee mug

Five-Minute Win: See Where Your Points Can Take You

Spend five minutes playing around with an award travel search tool.

If you've never used one before, I'd start with PointsYeah, especially their Daydream Explorer. Put in your home airport and see where your points could take you. You don't even need to have a trip in mind.

If you want to go deeper, Seats.aero and AwardTool are two other tools worth playing around with.


Knowing There Will Be Winners

I was listening to Tony Robbins on the Modern Wisdom podcast that came out yesterday, and he was waxing poetic about sophisticated investors, private equity and opportunities outside the public markets.

It immediately raised my spidey sense.

Not because I think nobody can outperform the stock market. Of course they can. But whenever I hear about an investment strategy that supposedly gives sophisticated investors an edge, I come back to Warren Buffett's famous $1 million bet.

In 2007, Buffett bet that a simple, low-cost S&P 500 index fund would outperform a collection of hedge funds selected by professional investors over the next ten years, net of taxes and fees.

The index fund won. By a lot.

It would be easy to extrapolate from this that nobody can beat the market, so don't even try. But I don't think that's the real lesson.

There's a huge gap between knowing there are investors who will outperform and believing I can identify them in advance, gain access to them, and retain the advantage after their fees.

The first one is obviously true. It's the second one that's so difficult.

At the end of the next decade, there will be stocks that returned 20% or 30% per year. There will be fund managers with incredible track records. There will be cities where real estate prices exploded.

We'll know exactly what we wish we'd invested in. But that doesn't help us today, because we're making the decision without the benefit of hindsight.

That's one of the reasons I've always found index investing so compelling. It doesn't require me to figure out who the winners will be. I can admit that I don't know and still participate in their success.

There will absolutely be winners.  I just don't need to know their names in advance.


A Few Things...

One of my favorite parts of writing this newsletter is spending the week with my eyes and ears open for things I think are worth sharing with you. It might be an idea from a conversation, something I read or listened to, a useful tool, or just something from my own life.

A Better Question

I listened to Vanessa Van Edwards on The Diary of a CEO talking about how much the quality of a conversation can change based on the question you start with.

Instead of the automatic “What do you do?” or “How are you?”, she suggests questions that give someone a chance to tell a story:

  • What was the highlight of your day?

  • Anything exciting you’re working on?

  • What’s your personal passion project?

And once you know someone better, you can go a little deeper:

  • What have you always wanted to learn?

  • What’s your biggest goal right now?

My current favorite: What have you changed your mind about recently?

Turning Off the Infinite Scroll

I noticed recently that I was starting to pick up my phone more often than I wanted to, and when I paid attention to what I was actually doing, it was almost always one of two things: Reddit or the Google feed on my Android phone.

It started out innocently enough, as I was just looking for info on my favorite soccer team, Arsenal. But I started noticing how much time was disappearing into apps with infinite scroll.

I deleted Reddit from my phone, which was an easy decision because it is a cesspool. But the bigger win was something Erin figured out: you can turn off the Google Discover feed entirely.

On Android, open the Google app → profile picture → Settings, search for Discover, and turn it off.

Now when I open that part of my phone or go to Google something, instead of an endless list of stories, there's nothing there.

We’re Not So Weird Anymore

I don't make many guest podcast appearances these days, but I recently joined Robert Brokamp on The Motley Fool's Hidden Gems Investing podcast to talk about the current state of the Financial Independence movement.

We talked about why you don't see nearly as many FIRE articles in the news anymore. A decade ago, FI was novel enough to be a story. Now it's everywhere. To a large degree, the core ideas of FI have simply become personal finance.

Or, as I put it on the podcast: “We used to be (considered) these frugal weirdos. And we’re not so weird anymore.”

The fundamentals haven't changed: “For most middle-class people, there’s precisely one way to get ahead financially: live below your means.”

Listen to The Current State of the Financial Independence Movement.

Family Weekend at William & Mary

We spent Saturday in Williamsburg for Family Weekend with Anna, including a scavenger hunt that had us running around town trying to decipher clues and find random landmarks.

It was ridiculous and surprisingly competitive, which is pretty much exactly what you want from a family scavenger hunt. We missed exactly one riddle that would have put us at the top of about 150 teams, and I’m embarrassed to report that we’re all still thinking about it.


Ten Years Later

It’s almost exactly 10 years since Jonathan and I first met in 2016, and lately I’ve been thinking about what ChooseFI has actually been about over that time.

I came across a line while reading Drownproof this week that put words to something I’ve been trying to articulate for years:

“Until you view yourself as the author of your life, you will be the victim of it.”

We’ve spent a decade talking about index funds, taxes, travel rewards, career moves, college, healthcare and hundreds of other topics. On the surface, that can look like a collection of financial tactics. But the people who seem to get the most out of ChooseFI don’t simply accumulate more tactics. They start approaching their lives differently.

They start questioning things they once assumed were fixed. If something looks complicated, they learn it. An expense that seemed unavoidable gets another look. If a career isn't what they hoped it would be, they look for another one. They stop assuming that the way things are is necessarily the way things have to be.

I think that’s why financial independence is so powerful. Money creates options, but the process of pursuing FI also teaches you to notice that you have options in the first place.

Ten years later, I think that may be the larger idea behind ChooseFI.

Become the author of your own life.


Around ChooseFI

A few things happening around the ChooseFI community...

Community Wins

One of the most-loved parts of the newsletter is the ChooseFI Community Taking Action section, and it only continues to exist because you share your wins.  Hit reply to this email and send in your win.

Local Groups

If you haven't already, take 30 seconds to join your local ChooseFI group. You'll automatically receive email notifications about meetups and events in your area.

Mark, one of our admins in San Diego, posted this about their recent meetup:

“Amazing case study event today with our San Diego group!

A big thank you to Ruth for having the courage to share her story and present such an interesting and thought-provoking case study. And thank you to everyone who contributed their insights, questions, and ideas - the discussion was fantastic!”

Continue the Conversation

Have thoughts or questions about this week's podcast? Join the discussion on Episode 618, where YNAB founder Jesse Mecham and I discuss the major shift from learning how to save to learning how to spend.

Travel Rewards

My Top Ten Recommended Travel Rewards Cards page is always up to date, including current welcome offers. If you're thinking about your next travel rewards card, that's the first place I'd look. 

If you apply using our links, ChooseFI earns a commission at no additional cost to you. This is how we're able to keep the podcast and newsletter ad-free. For nearly a decade, we've made the deliberate choice not to interrupt the podcast with traditional ad breaks, and I'd love to keep it that way. If you're going to apply for one of these cards anyway, using our link gets you the same offer, costs you nothing extra, and helps us keep ChooseFI ad-free. We're incredibly grateful.


ChooseFI Community Taking Action This Week

Hollie

My sister came up with the idea of a girl cousins retreat. She reached out to all of our cousins on our mom's side of the family and invited them to come spend the Labor day weekend at her house to reconnect and build friendships.

We have 22 cousins and in the end we had 6 show up. 4 which were my sisters. We had so much fun hiking, paddleboarding, laughing, sitting on the beach and everywhere we drove together was full of talking. There is a big age gap between our family and some of the cousins so it was a perfect opportunity to get to know them better.

This was possible for me to go since I am retired and have the free time and finances to do. I also noticed that since I walk regularly I was able to keep up with the younger girls on our aggressive hike. Fitness, time and money have allowed me those freedoms.

Brian

Your podcast this week hit very close to home.

I have been on a FI journey since 1989. I saved. I invested. I was patient. Teacher. Divorced. Remarried. One income. Etc.
12 years ago, in 2014 (60 years old), I was diagnosed with a very rare form of cancer. No cure. No treatment except emergency surgery to remove cancer cells and nearby lymph nodes.

One year ago, the cancer returned. Now stage 4. I am currently 72, and I have lived long enough that there is a treatment (not a cure).

I have set up my beneficiaries, invested, set up a family trust, funded charities, helped my grandkids on their paths, and lived my life the best I can.

My advice.

No one knows the future. Be prepared to change when necessary.

Cindy

Last Black Friday, I bought an annual pass to my local museum. I bought the most expensive one (about $100) because I got 2 membership cards (one went to my sister), 4 guest passes, invitations to members only events, etc.

But the best part is that the museum is a member of North American Reciprocal Museum (NARM) Association® which gives me reciprocity to over 1750 museums across the country! It's more than paid for itself and I'm looking forward to doing it again this year.

Here's an extra tip: you can change museums every year if you'd like. There are 5 museums here that are all NARM museums and I could join any of them. I'm staying where I'm at but it is an option.

Ben

I had left my 31 year W2 in the summer and have begun work as a 1099. Today I opened my Solo 401K. That took minutes.

Next comes the learning how to use and the funding -- but very soon, I will have truly self directed checkbook access to practically unlimited investment options from rental real estate to syndications & private alternatives + normal stocks and CDs. So excited to truly diversify!

Summer

I heard you talking about getting labs checked through function health and had a panel of labs checked through Superpower. I have been tired for a long time and figured it was chronic stress and getting older. Doctors would check my thyroid and hemoglobin and tell me labs were fine and to lose weight.

Found out through Superpower that my ferritin was very low! This is a solvable problem that contributes to many of my symptoms. (Headaches, hair thinning, and fatigue.) Started iron supplements a couple months ago and ferritin is already almost up to normal.

(I had been donating blood not knowing my iron was low because my hemoglobin was still fine!) Then - talking to Superpowers AI about my sleep data on my Garmin and my morning headaches it suggested a sleep study, which I did even though I did one a couple years ago - and found I have developed sleep apnea since my last test! Another solvable issue that could also be contributing to my fatigue.

I imagine losing the weight will be easier with more energy with the low iron and sleep apnea addressed! And - my Health Savings through work paid for it all. Much more than 1% win.

Allison

I had a mindset shift. I was raised by my mom, who grew up in an extremely rural environment and who herself was raised by survivors of the Great Depression and WWII rationing. There was always a philosophy of "buy it just in case" in my family.

This made sense when the nearest store was an hour away and you could be snowed in for weeks. But I live in an urban environment where the nearest store is 5 minutes away and the internet at my fingertips. So I've made myself some spending rules. I only buy if it's:
(1) a necessity (utilities, clothes to replace outgrown ones for the kids, groceries);
(2) Building freedom (shower organizers to make cleaning faster, precut garlic, scissors in every drawer); or
(3) creates joy (travel, dining experiences, movies, books, artwork, exercise equipment, etc).

There are exceptions to this rule, of course, but it's helped me see where my mindless spending was, like new clothes I didn't need. Not purchasing creates freedom, but so does understanding where I do and don't want to spend money.

Check your inbox

Click the link we just emailed you to confirm. Then every past and future edition of ChooseFI Weekly is yours.

Continue reading this issue

Get ChooseFI Weekly in Your Inbox

Join 100,000+ readers and get one practical, inspiring email every Monday to help you build the life you want.

Actionable insights 100K+ readers Unsubscribe anytime

Unlock 100+ past editions

Get instant access to our complete newsletter archive with 100+ issues on investing, lifestyle design, real estate, career, and more.

Up Next

Scroll up to cancel

Your FI Toolkit,
All in One Place

Preview the calculators, trackers, and planning tools that help you see exactly where you are—and what comes next.

Calculate your FI number

Track progress and milestones

Compare paths to FI

or

100% free — no credit card required

Account created! Redirecting...

Try searching for

⌘K to open anytime

Where Are You on the Path to FI?

1/3

Step 1 of 3

Which of these sounds most like you?

Scan to get the app

Point your phone camera at the QR code