Login
Financial Independence

Savings rate, FI number, and the path to freedom.

Retirement Strategies

Withdrawal plans, Roth ladders, and early access.

Investing

Index funds, asset allocation, and real estate.

Tax Strategies

Roth conversions, capital gains, and FI tax planning.

Earning More

Career growth, side hustles, and entrepreneurship.

Money Mindset

Beliefs, purpose, and financial psychology.

Health & Fitness

Exercise, nutrition, and mental wellness.

Deep Dive Hot Seat with Brad and Ginger
FI Fundamentals
Ep. 598 · · 54m 44s

Deep Dive Hot Seat with Brad and Ginger

Ginger asks Brad a series of hard hitting questions on life and FI.

Hosted by Ginger & Brad Barrett
0:00 / --:--

ChooseFI has partnered with CardRatings for our coverage of credit card products. ChooseFI and CardRatings may earn compensation from card issuers when a customer clicks on a link, when an application is approved, or when an account is opened. Opinions, reviews, analyses & recommendations are the author's alone, and have not been reviewed, endorsed or approved by any of these entities. American Express is a ChooseFI advertiser.

Brad's longevity assumptions might be completely wrong — not because he'll die sooner than expected, but because breakthrough research suggests he could live 20 to 30 years longer. That changes everything about financial independence planning, from withdrawal rates to the meaning of retirement itself.

Longevity Research and Retirement Planning | 00:03:15

Brad and Ginger examine David Sinclair's Harvard longevity research suggesting humans might live significantly longer than current actuarial tables predict. The discussion challenges conventional FI planning: if you're 44 and might live to 120 instead of 90, should you recalculate your numbers?

Brad argues most FI plans are already so conservative that even adding 20-30 years won't break them. Many people use 3% withdrawal rates when 4-5% may be perfectly safe. The money should last in perpetuity barring catastrophic scenarios — if you're aiming for a 100% success rate in retirement calculators, you've almost certainly oversaved.

Planning for Your Future Self | 00:13:20

Ginger shares how dramatically she's changed over 20 years in ways she never could have predicted. She used to love winter; now finds it deeply depressing. She became a morning person. Her travel preferences shifted from backpacking hostels to valuing comfort and nice hotels. These changes weren't failures of imagination — they were natural evolution.

The challenge: how do you plan for a future self you can't predict? Traditional bucket lists assume you'll want the same experiences in 20 years that appeal to you now. Brad and Ginger suggest embracing uncertainty, treating planning as an imagination exercise rather than a rigid roadmap, and leaving room for spontaneity.

The Die with Zero Dilemma | 00:21:45

They tackle Bill Perkins' "Die with Zero" framework — creating bucket lists mapped to different life stages. Brad appreciates the exercise but acknowledges he'd likely laugh at items he wrote years ago. The value isn't in perfect prediction but in forcing yourself to imagine possibilities beyond your current routine.

Ginger notes the tension between planning meaningful experiences and staying open to opportunities that can't be predicted. Some of life's most transformative moments come from serendipity, not spreadsheets.

Finding Meaning Beyond Money | 00:28:30

Can financial independence actually harm your sense of purpose? Ginger raises the example of someone who struggles with hobby projects once financial pressure disappears. Without the constraint of needing to monetize their passion, they lose motivation.

Brad pushes back: FI isn't about running away from work or doing nothing. The lack of meaning at its worst isn't fulfilling, but that's a personal development issue, not a financial one. Financial freedom gives you the space to find truly meaningful work — whether paid or unpaid — rather than staying trapped in a job chosen at 24.

The Controversial Take on Post-FI Work | 00:38:00

How Close Are You to Financial Independence?

Free calculators, a personalized FI roadmap, and a community of 25K+ on the same journey.

Brad delivers his most unpopular opinion: most people shouldn't stay in their jobs after reaching FI. His reasoning cuts deep: "You get one life and you're wasting it doing something just because you happen to have done it for the last ten, twenty, thirty years. I'm kind of sick and tired of that line of reasoning."

He argues the likelihood your current job — chosen when you were 19 or 24, probably driven by financial necessity — represents the highest use of your one precious life is "preposterously unlikely." With financial freedom, you have tens of billions of other options to explore. Staying in the same role reflects comfortable familiarity, not maximized potential.

The exception: if you genuinely believe your current work is your calling and you'd do it regardless of pay. But for most people? It's a failure of imagination masquerading as contentment.

Conservative Assumptions and Accuracy | 00:46:15

Frank Vasquez's research reframes how to think about FI numbers: piling conservative assumption upon conservative assumption doesn't make your number safer — it makes it wildly inaccurate. A 3% withdrawal rate plus conservative return assumptions plus pessimistic inflation projections doesn't equal safety; it equals oversaving by potentially hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Brad notes: "A one hundred percent success rate when we run our numbers means actually it's one hundred percent that you oversaved." You might delay FI by years chasing an unnecessarily large number.

He also critiques the "middle class trap" concept suggesting people can't comfortably withdraw from retirement accounts. His blunt take: if you're uncomfortable doing hard things or making financial decisions without a paycheck, that's a maturity issue, not proof that FI doesn't work.

Managing Anxiety and Self-Care | 00:51:30

Brad opens up about his journey with anxiety, sharing practical tools that work for him:

  • Acupressure mat ($40) combined with meditation for 20-30 minutes
  • Yoga Nidra (Non-Sleep Deep Rest) — guided meditation providing nervous system reset benefits
  • Outdoor time — 30-60 minutes daily, especially in sunlight
  • Exercise — strength training 3x per week plus two daily 30-minute walks
  • Early intervention — recognizing physical anxiety triggers (tightness, shallow breathing) before mental spiraling begins

He emphasizes these aren't cures but management tools. The goal is creating space between stimulus and response, catching anxiety early rather than letting it escalate.

Notable Quotes

Brad Barrett: "You get one life and you're wasting it doing something just because you happen to have done it for the last ten, twenty, thirty years. I'm kind of sick and tired of that line of reasoning."

Ginger: "We aren't just articulating thoughts we have. We are actively reflecting, changing, defining ourselves through our conversations."

Brad Barrett: "A one hundred percent success rate when we run our numbers means actually it's one hundred percent that you oversaved."

Brad Barrett: "FI is not about running away from a job and it's not about retiring per se. The lack of meaning, the lack of doing anything at its worst, that's not a fulfilling life."

Ginger: "I used to love winter. Now I find winter deeply depressing. I could not have imagined this for myself, and so I wonder what are the other ways that I will change."

Key Takeaways

  • Recalculate your FI number using accurate (not overly conservative) assumptions to avoid unnecessary oversaving
  • Try a 20-30 minute Yoga Nidra or NSDR meditation session to experience nervous system reset benefits
  • Create a Die with Zero bucket list knowing you'll laugh at some items later — treat it as an imagination exercise
  • Consider an acupressure mat ($40) combined with meditation for anxiety management
  • Spend 30-60 minutes outside daily, especially in sunlight, to improve mental health
  • Identify your anxiety triggers and physical sensations, then create intervention protocols before spiraling
  • Incorporate strength training 3x per week and two daily 30-minute walks for mental and physical health
  • Question whether your current job is truly the highest use of your life if you're near or at FI
  • Leave room for spontaneity in your calendar even when planning trips and experiences
  • Join your local ChooseFI community at choosebetter.com/login to discuss these questions with others

Resources Mentioned

Top Travel Card

Ready to unlock a world of free travel? Start with the Chase Sapphire Preferred® Card

$95 annual fee | Earn 75,000 bonus points

Best Card for Side Hustlers and Business Owners

Side hustlers! With the Ink Business Preferred® Credit Card you can earn free travel from your business expenses.

$95 annual fee | Earn 100,000 bonus points

Most Flexible Travel Card

The Capital One Venture Rewards Credit Card can be used to offset almost any travel expense.

$95 annual fee | Earn more than $1,000 in Travel Bonuses with a limited-time $300 Capital One Travel stays credit, plus earn 75,000 bonus miles once you spend $4,000 on purchases within the first 3 months of account opening—that's more than $1,000 in travel value

ChooseFI has partnered with CardRatings for our coverage of credit card products. ChooseFI and CardRatings may receive a commission from card issuers.

  • Acupressure Mat
  • Diary of a CEO Episode with David Sinclair
  • Yoga Nidra / NSDR Meditations
  • Projection Lab (FI Planning Software)
  • Die with Zero by Bill Perkins
  • Andrew Huberman (NSDR/Neuroscience Content)
  • Mad Fientist Podcast
  • Camp FI Retreats
  • ChooseFI Community Platform at choosefi.com/login
Loading transcript...

Acupressure Mat: https://www.amazon.com/ProSource-Acupressure-Pillow-Relief-Rela...

Diary of a CEO Episode with David Sinclair: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DnvW...

Comments (12)

Your comment will be posted after signing in
KaySueBee 4 months ago

This episode might have been the tipping point where I realized that I have outgrown this podcast and especially Brad. In this episode he says.."you're going to be ok….you're not going to run like a lemming off a hill into $0 and eat cat food. There's no world where your future is eating cat food." Honestly, we just don't know. I think it's ok to pad things. What if you are sued, have serious medical debt, your spouse is convicted of a crime, your child needs medical treatments not covered by insurance? I think it's ok to be overly conservative, and I don't need Brad beating me down for it. I see a lot of people on the FB group saying "can I retire with X amount?" and others will say no. We don't all make the best decisions. So you retire and then you haven't saved enough. I think Brad also really struggled with the question about meaning. He never addressed it which makes me think that he doesn't get it. Also, he really beats people up for the quick pain of taking your first withdrawal after FIRE but he himself has discussed his anxiety about doing this!!

Westie 4 months ago

I know they mentioned there was a camp FI breakout session on this but I wish they'd have an episode about how much is reasonable to pad retirement numbers. And I think we should have an episode allllll about insurance, which would address the catastrophic type blows to your retirement you mention above. Insurance (not just health insurance but many types of insurance) is super important in your financial plan but chooseFI hasn't focused much on it. I can't remember if it was chooseFI or Money With Katie, but I remember a great podcast episode which interviewed a very high earning woman who after becoming disabled suddenly was able to continue receiving her high salary indefinitely and live an excellent retired life despite the disability, due to her proper choice of insurance products.

Happyjolteon 5 months ago

I think it was this episode, might have been the next one as I was listening while walking, but! Just wanted to comment about the mention of the new credit card tracking section of the ChooseFI site.

I already had a Google Sheet with my opening dates, but had dropped the ball on renewals. As a result of adding cards on the site, I discovered that the Capital One Venture card, which I misremembered as being free, was $95 a year and had just renewed. I got the signup bonus long ago and we're no longer using it, so I made the 5 minute call to close it out and got the $95 refunded.

Thank you for the reminder, and I look forward to using that tool on your site again in the future!

nathangrimm 5 months ago

I'm at 36:14.

Hard disagree with Brad that it's preposterous that people have found their highest and best use of time in their career.

There's a framework that attributes purpose, autonomy, mastery, and community as the core pillars of deep intrinsic motivation and fulfillment. If you have been intentional at all in your career, you have probably made great strides at developing each of these four pillars over the decades you've been investing in your work.

There isn't a randomly selected highest and best use of time for each person. It's something that is developed and worked at. Thoughtful, planful people who are on their way to FI or have achieved it have likely developed a huge amount of purpose and fulfillment in their current job.

I would go so far to say that if you're on your way to FI and plan to quit your job the day you hit your FI number, you should shift your focus to try to develop purpose, autonomy, mastery, and community in your work. You should not waste the next few years to decades of your life without attempting that. If it pushes back your FI date, it's worth it.

Westie 4 months ago

Why should we want fulfillment from our work? It's just a thing we have to do. To me that's like suggesting we should find purpose and meaning in our daily commutes, or our daily showers. (Or our daily workout, which some people do find meaning in and I also don't understand that)

Elisabeth 6 months ago

Maybe we need a Guided Meditation for Drawing Down. Some years ago JL Collins kindly indulged my request for a Guided Meditation for When the Stock Market is Dropping. Now I think we might need the corollary to that "don't sell" recording featuring Saucy/Tough Love Brad telling us to "sell already."

2
TiaGrace 6 months ago

Wait a minute, did Brad and Erin get back together!? What did I miss?? Or was I imagining that he said “Erin & I” several times? 🤔

1
NickCincyFI 6 months ago

Um… His ex wife's name was Laura– seem's he is now dating a gal named Erin. I'm happy for him.

1 1
LaraSutton 6 months ago

Anxiety

My daughter has some issues with anxiety. She took some medication briefly but did not want to stay on it full time. I have often told her that her peace has to come from within. She is the only person who can control her thoughts.

She and I have also been trying to lose weight. I have struggled with my weight my whole life. I am not at my highest but I am too close. I was considering a GLP1 but in some of the talks with my daughter, I finally had the realization that “Food noise” which is what those medications are supposed to help is not much different than anxiety noise. I have been putting my own advise to practice and cutting the food noise out. I’m down 17 pounds so far and neither of us are taking medications! She’s lost around 30 but she started sooner.

2 1
juliecompton 6 months ago

Always great to listen to the discussions and perspectives… since I’m 62, there’s diff outlooks to some of the topics that are so common in the FI community as most people are younger…

However, making memories I believe is the focus of our lives, nothing else we take with us or leave behind with others that is more valuable!

And Ginger, I’m in Boise when you come for your race, please connect , happy to host even!

1
Buffy 6 months ago

I’m 58 and in Boise. I, too, was trying to figure out a way to meet Ginger when she comes to race. Would you be open to a group meet?

1
GingerG 6 months ago

Oh my gosh, how nice are you. I am dragging a friend DRAGGING-ha- so I don’t think adding a meetup will be doable this time around.

rcost300 6 months ago

Really enjoyed this episode. What it brought to mind was how this idea that "you have to retire to something" that has taken hold in the FI community of late, really doesn't track with my own experience transitioning into FI two years ago. I didn't dislike my job, but as Ginger pointed out, I didn't want to spend so many hours on it anymore, and given the reality of my industry where performative busyness was culturally valued, there wasn't the option to scale back hours - it was all or nothing. I simply did not have the headspace to even think about what was next while still working. So upon hitting FI, I walked away without a plan, and gave myself the time freedom to take long walks, travel, and really think - and that's what set me on the path to starting a business, several months after leaving the corporate world, doing something I'm passionate about.

4 3
Nate Meharg 6 months ago

Longevity Research and Retirement Planning

For me personally, FI calculations are helpful frameworks, but I’ve basically realized I’m already CoastFI and getting close to LeanFI. At this point, I’m less focused on chasing a bigger number and more focused on optimizing for simplicity. Once life is optimized around what actually matters, additional dollars mostly just go toward whatever the next goals or opportunities are.

I also think a lot of FI models are already extremely conservative. At some point, there’s diminishing returns in optimizing for certainty.

Planning for Your Future Self

One thing I know for sure is that my circumstances and desires will change over time. I try to stay flexible, not just financially, but mentally and emotionally too. I often go through thought exercises about different futures: What if my wife passed away? What if my kids moved away? What would I value then?

Right now, I know our kids are a huge priority because we only get a limited amount of time with them before adulthood. But maybe later in life flexibility means traveling more or helping with future grandkids so my kids don’t have to struggle with childcare the way we did.

I don’t think the goal is perfectly predicting your future self. I think the goal is staying adaptable enough to evolve with life.

Die with Zero Philosophy

The challenge I have with the Die with Zero philosophy is actually the same problem I have with extreme financial conservatism. At the end of the day, both can operate out of fear.

One side fears not having enough money in the bank. The other fears not maximizing enough experiences or “memory dividends.” Both are trying to “win” life in some measurable way.

But life is vapor — hevel. Here one moment and gone the next.

We can be wise. We can be good stewards. We can intentionally craft the kind of life we want to live. But ultimately, I try to stay present rather than obsess over optimization.

That said, I do appreciate how Die with Zero challenges people to think beyond safety and security. There is absolutely an opportunity cost to delaying experiences forever.

Finding Meaning Beyond Money

I’ve always viewed money as a tool. It’s something I can use to support the things I value most.

For me, my faith guides that. Following Jesus and living out the teachings of the text shapes how I think about life, work, money, and purpose. Financial resources and other gifts simply become tools that help me live that out.

I also really appreciate Alan and Katie Donegan’s “extraordinary life” framework because it pushes people to deeply examine what they actually value instead of blindly following cultural defaults. I think meaning comes from understanding those values first. Then the work, projects, and pursuits naturally flow from there.

Post-FI Work

I don’t necessarily think everyone should immediately quit their jobs once they reach FI. I think the better question is: “What would I do if I were financially free?” Then try to optimize your life toward that today instead of waiting for some magical future date.

That’s largely what I’ve tried to do myself. But I also recognize there will probably be future changes I can’t predict yet.

4 4
Elisabeth 6 months ago

Thank you for teaching me a new word and concept - hevel. So much to unpack in that!

travisleffel 6 months ago

I think Brad’s interpretation of the Middle Class Trap is a strawman. It isn’t really about being uncomfortable with selling assets. It’s about how having all of your assets in home equity and retirement accounts makes things inflexible. The poster child for the Middle Class Trap is a 38 year old millionaire with 300k in home equity and 700k in retirement accounts but they still have a mortgage. That person is doing great, but how are they going to make early retirement actually happen if they stay on the path they are on? Their options are quite limited. Take the 10% penalty? A giant 72(t)? This is the “trap”.

5
bryano 6 months ago

I think that's where the recently-dropped RE of FIRE came into play, because they've put their eggs in hard-to-reach baskets. I don't have any good ideas for the equity because it would either be to pull it and use that money to live, which means you still need to work to make the higher payment), or pull it and buy a rental, which is just another longer term delay before the cash flow gets to where it makes a difference. For the 401k, I think it depends on if it's traditional or roth. Employer contributions are traditional, so it's possible there's roth funds that can be pulled out without penalty. I've also heard of the roth conversion ladder, but I'm not sure if you can use it on a 401k that's still with your active employer.

Trc4897 6 months ago

To me, this person you are describing is not a millionaire. Sure they are a net worth millionaire, but I feel like home equity should not be included in a FIRE number at all. If they do not have anything in a brokerage account, they do seem like they are "trapped". And a 72t would be their (only?) way out of it. Hopefully most people would at least have some amount of Roth IRA contributions or Brokerage account monies they could pull out while starting a Roth Conversion Ladder instead. What percentage of people do you think have 100% of their money tied up in pretax retirement accounts? I hope it is very small

1
Henry 6 months ago

I agree Brad didn't address the trap definition exactly, but the trap is a bit overblown though and it is a strawman by including the house value in the FI consideration. That 38 year old millionaire you describe simply isn't FI yet. Total net worth is not your FI number, and that 'millionaire' has a FI net worth of 700k. Doing great but most likely not FI.

At the 2.5M net worth that Scott and Mindy talk about, it's unlikely someone who has 2.5M of actual FI net worth (not stuck in their house) still has all of that stuck in a traditional 401k with nothing else. But even if they did, at that point, yes, a giant 72(t) gets them out of the trap.

ATreth 6 months ago (edited)

Thanks you two for another fab episode. Re: longevity…My parents are still alive (80 & 84). And my grandparents' ages at death average 92 years old (98, 90, 88). So when I forecast I go all the way to age 100! And my forecasts show that I'll have money all the way to age 100. Even with all this financial security, I know that I'm too conservative.

Even 25 years ago when I felt work anxiety I used to "count my money" to give myself a sense of security. Now that I'm retired I'm having a hard time letting go of that impulse. I'm not good at dreaming big, but after this episode and the one from last week, I'm going to try harder. I sometimes feel like I'm not present enough: I forecast the future using all kinds of different scenarios, and I appreciate my past success when I look at my spreadsheets and net worth. But I need to work on focusing more on the present! Old habits are hard to break but I'm gonna try!

4
JC1218 6 months ago

On this thought of longevity risk being MUCH more of a problem if our money must last until age 100, or 120 this is a pretty big issue. I know the FIRE community generally has a distaste for annuities, but in response to this specific dilemma why wouldn't a SPIA be a viable way of alleviating this concern at least partially despite the up front fee drag? If one lives to 120, then that SPIA will likely have turned out to have a pretty decent ROI.

2 1
ATreth 6 months ago

I've thought of that too. But I wonder if those would be fixed and not adjusted for inflation? One of my worst-case options if I live longer than I expect might be a reverse mortgage (also distasteful to FI folks). But I have no heirs and again - that would just be a worst case scenario.

1 1
roberto - 6 months ago

If you live in the US, then remember you already have an annuity in the form of Social Security. That's not to say that you can't purchase a SPIA. Depending on a variety of factors, a SPIA might be a really good direction to go. However, it helps to keep the framing of "I'm going from 1 annuity to 2 annuities" rather than "I'm going from 0 annuities to 1 annuity".

5
Henry 6 months ago

Surely the costs of annuities would rise in line with life expectancies extending, so I'm not sure you would gain anything. Also, unless the annuity adjusts for inflation, a longer life span would increase your inflation risk exposure with an annuity, making it even less attractive.

I think many people don't realize that the safe withdrawal rate of a portfolio doesn't increase in line with the withdrawal duration (length of retirement), but it is asymptotic to some number not much above the 30 year safe withdrawal rate. So technically a 40, 50, 60, and even 100 year retirement can all be covered with roughly the same SWR (the perpetual SWR). That perpetual SWR is only about 0.5-1% higher than the original 4% SWR based on a 30 year retirement from the Trinity study, which also used a number of very conservative assumptions. So I think Brad's answer was pretty spot on.

2
Join the Conversation

Create an account or sign in to post a comment.

Calculate Your FI Number

See exactly how much you need to retire on your terms. Get a personalized plan in seconds.

Trusted by 30,000+ members

Model pensions, Social Security & life changes

100% free — no credit card required

or

100% free — no credit card required

Account created! Redirecting...

Try searching for

⌘K to open anytime

Where Are You on the Path to FI?

1/3

Step 1 of 3

Which of these sounds most like you?

Scan to get the app

Point your phone camera at the QR code